Fair
weather feminism hypocritical
Many people consider the birth of U.S. feminism
to be the women’s suffrage movement, or
the entrance of many women from the home
to the workplace during World War II. People
have argued that until the birth control
pill was widely available, the ever-present
prospect of maternity made it difficult
for women to compete with men in the workplace.
Aside from feminist scholars and activists,
most people assume that feminist goals have
been largely realized in the United States.
While there have been many changes in the
workplace, laws and gender relations, gender
equality has not yet been realized.
Feminist has the popular connotation of
a shrill, angry woman who views every aspect
of popular culture through the lens of gender,
considers all men oppressors and potential
rapists and loathes any aspect of her femaleness
that she cannot attribute to enculturation.
Many educated, contemporary women refuse
to identify themselves as feminists. While
they may consider themselves modern, self-sufficient,
equal to male peers and support gender equality,
they shudder to call themselves feminists.
Many contemporary women see feminism as
conflicting lipstick, enjoying more traditional
relationships with men and taking a more
balanced approach toward gender, considering
men and women different, if still equal.
The Merriam-Webster online dictionary defines
feminism as both “the theory of the political,
economic, and social equality of the sexes”
and “organized activity on behalf of women’s
rights and interests.”
Unfortunately, much of contemporary feminism
ignores the first definition, focusing instead
on pursuing women’s political, economic
and social rights and interests, ignoring
how sexism may negatively impact men.
Many of the young women who benefit from
feminism, but do not identify as feminists,
alternately lay claim to rights procured
for them by feminism or rights traditionally
allowed to them by sexist values, according
to whichever provides the greatest benefit
— the “fair weather feminists.”
A trivial example would be a woman who smiles
to encourage the chivalry of her male colleague
who carries a heavy package for her into
the office, then expects to be paid the
same amount as he does because they are
equal. After work, she is taken to dinner
by her fiancé, who pays for the entire
meal because it is so romantic. Later, when
her fiancé is her husband and he
expects her to handle all the housework,
she calls him a sexist Neanderthal.
Men were trained to hold doors open for
women because women were the weaker sex.
Men traditionally paid for dates because
they had better job opportunities and their
salaries were consistently higher. After
they were married, a man was expected to
support his wife, who would be dependent
on him.
The fair weather feminist enjoys the benefits
of feminism and considers them fair. But,
she also exploits sexism and calls it romantic,
considering herself neither feminist nor
sexist.
Many fair weather feminists describe themselves
as a “modern woman with a romantic side
that still likes to feel feminine,” but
they are opportunistic hypocrites. Rather
than blending aspects of two belief systems,
they skim the benefits from both and incur
the costs of neither, being either an equal
or a lady as it suits them.
Feminists never concerned themselves with
the negative impact of sexism upon men.
In the 1960s, while bras blazed and women
demanded paid maternity leave, recognition
of their sexual needs and equals rights,
they did not insist that women should also
be drafted into military service. They never
demanded to die in Vietnam.
It is not the sole responsibility of women
to implement equality in everyone’s lives.
Rather, both men and women should attempt
to have relationships that are consistent
and fair. A woman who expects a man to spend
more on her than she spends on him should
not resent his expectation that she will
do more housework — either they have a traditional
relationship, or they do not.
A woman who resents a man on a crowded bus
who does not offer her his seat should not
feel resentment when male colleagues are
taken more seriously in meetings. A woman
should not expect men to leave toilet seats
down to accommodate her unless she thinks
she needs a man to make all important decisions
for her. Women who don’t go dutch on dates,
stand on crowded buses, lower their own
toilet seats and open their own doors don’t
deserve equality. Men cannot be blamed for
failing to believe the sexes are equal when
feminism continues to be lady’s choice.
Many men are guilty of exploiting feminism
to indulge their selfishness. Many men have
wives or girlfriends who do all the cooking
and housework, but work full-time. Some
men use feminism as a rationale for abandoning
women that they have gotten pregnant, since
“women do not need men anymore to raise
a child.” Men and women are both guilty
of exploiting advantages that feminism seems
to allow them.
The difference lies in when blame is placed.
Men whose wives also work full-time are
widely considered jerks if they do not do
their share of the housework. Men who expect
the women in their office to wash all the
coffee cups in the office kitchenette are
called sexist pigs. Men who leer at women
on the street are Neanderthals. Women who
work full-time and want their boyfriend
to pay for all their dates and buy them
flowers and other gifts aren’t widely considered
jerks, they are considered romantic. Women
who expect equal pay for doing the same
job but expect men to move heavy office
furniture for them are not called sexist
pigs, they called are old-fashioned. Women
who dress in a sexually provocative manner
in order to manipulate men aren’t Neanderthals,
they are Erin Brockovich.
In order for women to be equals, they have
to give up fair weather feminism. A woman
ca not expect to experience the benefits
of equality or sexism as ladie’s choice.
Men can not be expected to muster the strength
to overturn established sexual roles or
respect women as equals if women claim a
continuing right to be old-fashioned, sentimental
and romantic. In order for sexual equality
to be real, women need to do more than just
fight traditional limitations placed upon
them — they need to give up traditional
female privileges.
David Alexander is a student at Cal State
Long Beach.
|