Democracy
will be difficult in Iraq
The war is won, or so they’re telling us.
Saddam is likely nothing more than miniscule
particles clogging up the locals’ lungs
— one last hurrah for the debonair dictator.
Even Saddam’s stone and bronze personal
monuments are tumbling, but not with nearly
the panache of eight thousand pounds of
American-made explosives.
The war has indeed been won, but I must
hesitate to say it’s over. Iraqi Information
Minister Muhammed al-Sahhaf will certainly
be quick to dismiss a statement so bold.
That loon should host a game show now that
his tour is complete. Or maybe he should
judge top-tier, competitive ice-skating.
No man since Ed McMahon was born better
suited for the spotlight.
But, what have we learned — aside from al-Sahhaf’s
eccentric brand of playacting? We’ve learned
that the majority of the American people
will kick and scream and sit-in until the
first tanks roll, but will then turn on
a dime into a state of resigned disapproval
coupled with undying support for Our Boys.
We’ve learned that President Bush comes
off like Foghorn Leghorn when sharing a
podium with the exceedingly eloquent Tony
Blair. But speaking skills aside, Bush just
might have done this thing right. Not completely
right of course — he loses points on my
scorecard for denying the world a down home,
kick-ass War Crimes Tribunal. Imagine the
spectacle if al-Sahhaf served as Saddam’s
defense counsel!
We’ve also learned that the strict information
control first implemented by Margaret Thatcher
in the Falkland Islands fiasco and later
perfected in Gulf War I was the biggest
mistake in media-government relations. The
embedding program has gone beyond expectations
in the amount of not only tactical information
the world is privy to — but more importantly
the personal, human stories. And, to boot,
we are seeing live pictures of things we’ve
never seen before in a place we never really
wanted to see.
We’ve learned that even Pentagon experts
and Washington witchdoctors can be wrong,
or at least a few degrees off. The U.S.
military has performed with poise and skill
surpassing all expectations. It’s amazing
what a few years, a little technology and
heaping piles of cash can do for a fighting
force. Iraqi forces were given far too much
credit early on — especially the Republican
Guard. After accidents and friendly fire,
coalition forces suffered the most casualties
at the hands of guerrilla, paramilitary
units — groups that were lumped in with
the rag-tag forces that the experts predicted
would surrender.
Who am I kidding? I imagine someone once
said that indoctrination is a bitch. Not
that I’m consumed by liberal guilt or patriotic
fervor. Maybe I just feed on the Action.
Or, I’m naïve to believe that Saddam
is dead. This thing is not over. It probably
never will be. A merely 200-some-odd-year-old
superpower cannot even begin to understand
the cultural barometer of a region steeped
in thousands of years of tradition and conflict
and brutal history. A quarter pound of freedom
with a side of Halliburton is a volatile
meal for Iraq and the rest of the Middle
East.
Ding!
Dong! The Regime is Dead!
Eight thousand pounds of freedom, dropped
on its head!
The desert swathed across Iraq and the Middle
East is a yellow brick road, long ago worn
to dust. We’ve learned some surprising things
in a three-week liberation-conquest, but
the real lessons have yet been taught.
Greg Smith is a journalism major at
Cal State Long Beach.
|