The concept of Native Americans as a dying race has been popular throughout American history, and it was revived in the early twentieth century. Many painters of the time depicted Native Americans in a way which suggested nostalgia for the way of life the Indians had lost. In this 1922 oil painting by John Innes, an elderly Indian is looking at a buffalo skull, while the ghosts of hunters and buffalos--symbols representing the lost Native American way of life--appear in the sky above him. In the course of the nineteenth century, certain tribes became extinct or suffered severe depopulation as a result of disease, conquest, and poverty, but it was a common misconception among whites that the Indians were vanishing as a whole.